Recent Rumour of Hyorin - Is she greedy like they say?

I came across an article on kpopfans blog here discussing a girlgroup member A

This women told a story
"Girl group member A is musically talented
But her looks lack a little

Her group got a photoshoot offer for a worldwide beauty brand

A got greedy and wanted to do more photoshoots like this

She decided to seduce the brand's boss who is a foreigner

At the after-party, A successfully seduced him with her skinship

A slept with the boss at that night and became his "girlfriend"

A is not fluent in English

"You don't need to be fluent in English to sleep with someone..."

A started coming to the brand company as if it was her home

She even took a bunch of the makeups

A then told the boss to use her as the brand model

The boss asked the workers to use her as the model

They were terrified and strongly refused it because her body and her skin did not match

After A found it out, she said she'll get rid of the workers

She went to them and forced them to bow down to her

A has big breasts and muscular thighs"

I have 2 theories for this, here's the first one:

Okay let's get to some details here because this is a very well-constructed lie, why you may ask?

1. GG A is musically talented

Musically talented? To most people the first idea that pops to their head is the ability to sing. But in fact musical talents go to much greater depth: "Musical talents show sensitivity in pitch, rhythm, and timbre" (Howard Gardner's Book). This also includes the ability to play instruments, rap, pinpoint the on-playing instrument and repeat the notes,etc... Being musically talented doesn't necessarily means singing well, it can also mean A is able to play instruments or sing decently. Using the term "musically talented" can be very misleading to most people, and does she use that term unintentionally? I don't think so...

2. "But her looks lack a little"

This doesn't state the prospective of the speaker or the public

This point is almost a hit. Since Korean people, with their skyhigh expectations usually say that "Hyorin is ugly". But don't forget a lot of idols get called ugly too (and usually most of them are main vocalists of the group. We also don't know if A is really ugly, or the speaker is just saying so to further imply A is Hyorin. Not surprising if most people fall for this.

3. "Her group got a photoshoot offer for a worldwide beauty brand"

SISTAR never got a photoshoot offer of a worldwide beauty brand. Do I need to say more?

4." A got greedy and wanted to do more photoshoots like this

She decided to seduce the brand's boss who is a foreigner

At the after-party, A successfully seduced him with her skinship

A slept with the boss at that night and became his "girlfriend"

A is not fluent in English

"You don't need to be fluent in English to sleep with someone..."

Ouch! Someone seems a bit angry,doesn't she?

This seems to be a perfectly logical thing to say, except she knows it too well. And only lies need details.

"A successfully seduced him with her skinship". Was she there to witness? Or she was told by another person who was there? But she stated with such certainty, she HAS to have been there, did she? But what did she do in a after-party of a cf if she wasn't the model or the staff? huuhhhm not too obvious isn't it?

Also "She slept with the boss" accuse. Did they tell her they were going to the hotel and get it on? Or the staff followed the boss home or to the hotel to find out then conveniently told her that "Yeah they totally did the do". This is a private situation, the boss should have been as careful as he could. Such evidence don't you think?

Last but not least, "not fluent in English" - most idols aren't influent in English. How shocking!

5. "A started coming to the brand company as if it was her home

She even took a bunch of the makeups

A then told the boss to use her as the brand model

The boss asked the workers to use her as the model

They were terrified and strongly refused it because her body and her skin did not match

After A found it out, she said she'll get rid of the workers

She went to them and forced them to bow down to her"

Oopsie someone has been naughty. Once again, she knows too much. Was she a staff to even know the inside of the photoshoot? Also she must have been at the company for quite some time to know that " A started coming to the company as if it was her home"? Or she heard the rumour and added some elegant touches there?

Then we have another problem with "the foreign boss" of a worldwide beauty brand. Is he likely to be a person easily manipulated by sex? And please, it's not like he's inexperienced and naive in this.

"Her body and skin doesn't match". What does this means? Does it mean her skin is too dark? Or too pale? Was her skin in bad condition? What about her body? She wasn't tall enough? Not skinny enough? Too skinny?

Koreans are all about pale skin and skinny bodies. A very clever way to misinterpret at first glance indeed.

And we have come to the key point. After all this fuss, why didn't she mention if A got the cf deal. To her own accord, the staff were forced to bow down to A, so most likely A DID get a cf (balance of probability). And did Hyorin get any worldwide beauty brand cf?

No.

So she cleverly avoids the key point to show A is not Hyorin.

Since everyone is most likely to make their own assumptions and fall prey to the lies, all she had to do is adding the finishing touch 

"A has big breasts and muscular thighs"
Icing to the cake at its finest.

My second theory: She's telling the truth but it's some random nugu idol who has some similar features as Hyorin because:

1. SISTAR never had a worldwide beauty brand cf.

2. Hyorin is famous for her straightforward-ness and honesty. Would I be able to act like that if I did something so shady? I'd rather keep my image cute and innocent.

3. Hyorin is known for her modesty and respect for other people. It's not my opinion, it's Korean artists' who have worked with her.

4. Hyorin and seducing a man? Are we even talking about the same person? The person who locked herself in her room for 2 months because she was scared to meet people and rather spend time with her dogs and cats?

My money is on the first theory, because K-showbiz has never been pink. It is a black quicksand that threatens to drown people if they start to gain some success.

This article annoys me so much for it practically insults Hyorin and everything her fans believe in. Also I'm tired of all the shitty rumour to bring SISTAR down. I try to keep my ranting logical and fact-based though.
I hope my 2 cents make sense.
Keep calm and love Hyorin <3